TEAMtalk Editor Simon Wilkes shares the Aston Villa fans' sheer disbelief that Randy Lerner is trying to appoint Alex McLeish as manager.
Villa fans: In a state of shock
What on earth is Randy Lerner thinking?
I was on TEAMtalk duty when the story broke on Sunday that Alex McLeish had resigned as Birmingham boss by email - and nearly fell off my chair when he was immediately installed as favourite for the vacant Villa Park hot-seat.
Having grown up in Lichfield, just 15 miles from Birmingham city centre, most of my family and old school/college mates are either Villa or Blues fans (I'm a lone Albion supporter) so I'm inherently aware of the hatred that exists between the two clubs.
I genuinely believed the conspiracy theories that the McLeish talk was an initial smokescreen and that Villa were poised to recruit David Moyes from Everton, with the former Rangers gaffer going to Goodison.
The only reason I believed that was because the thought of McLeish crossing the city to take charge of Villa was simply unfathomable - especially as his stock has never been lower after being captain of Birmingham's sinking ship, which is now docked in the Championship.
I know he ended Blues' long wait for silverware by lifting the Carling Cup last season - and yes he won trophies aplenty at Ibrox before taking over the reins of the Scotland national team.
But McLeish's managerial style of play could not be further from that demanded by the Villa fanbase, and I simply can't accept that the Villa board have "taken his tenure at our local rivals and the strong emotions associated with this very seriously", as they claimed on Tuesday night.
I can confidently predict that if Lerner ploughs on with this strategy, it will be the most unpopular appointment in Premier League history.
There was a backlash on Merseyside when Roy Hodgson got the gig as Rafael Benitez's successor - but there was a large number of Liverpool fans who at least gave the former Manager of the Season a chance at Anfield, and only turned against him when results and performances were not up to scratch.
In this case, there will be no honeymoon period for McLeish - and even if he has thick enough skin to take the abuse that will no doubt come his way from the stands, it will cause a poisonous, destructive atmosphere among the Villa squad and in the dressing room.
Villa fans are already reeling from the news that Ashley Young has all-but sealed a big-money move to Manchester United, with his fellow England winger Stewart Downing likely to also head through the exit door this summer.
So Lerner is basically kicking them when they're down with this move, and to get a feel of the sheer shock reverberating around the Midlands, here are a handful of messages from TEAMtalk's Villa Your Say board:
avfc_yup (Aston Villa): I'm not relly sure what to say to be honest my head is all over the place I want to keep believing its just part of a smoke screen for a bigger and better appointment but I dont think I believe it anymore! The statement pretty much says it all for me - it sounds like he's getting the job and they are trying to bring us down gentely. Dont get me wrong he's the last person I want as our manager but regardless we have got to get behind the team or it could be even worse than we already think it may be.
sam the mouse (Aston Villa): I've been giving Randy the benefit of the doubt so far, trying to keep faith that he has a good plan for the future and we just don't know about it yet. Well, Gingerscotti may not have signed on the dotted line yet but it's clearly going to happen. So now I'm letting rip: OH. MY. GOD. What do the board think they are playing at? This is going to be a total sodding disaster. Useless manager, relegation specialist, utterly terrible football, never going to attract any top quality players or hold onto the good ones we do have. We'll never be on the telly, until the last day of the season when everyone tunes in to watch a proud club lose its Premiership status for the first time. The atmos at the first home game will be dripping in poison. If you thought things were bad under Houllier, you ain't seen nothing yet. And what must the squad be thinking? All our pretensions of ambition are going to look pretty empty now. We can kiss Downing goodbye, he'll be gone by August. Bent will probably follow him by January. But hey, why worry because we can all look forward to watching Cameron Jerome running about up front on his own. Oh, and we'll no doubt end up spending 15 million or something stupid on Foster too, who's no better than Brad Guzan. I literally cannot believe this is happening. Utterly, utterly inexplicable.
villansoph (Aston Villa): "Managers come and go but Aston Villa will always be Aston Villa", people say. But what is a football club without fans? What is the purpose of a football club if it has nobody to attend each game or buy its merchandise? Fans constitute the meaning behind Aston Villa F.C. Pity the General and co. don't see it that way. Fans are the most vital cog in any football club. Regardless of what does and doesn't make one 'a good fan' or a 'loyal fan', they should be one of the most important influences in any decision. All this talk of "Villa as a business" - spare me. How is putting us at the behest of somebody who has been relegated twice in four seasons a good business strategy? That long-haired idiot from the Apprentice would know better. Disillusioned.
villan73 (Aston Villa): I realise this might upset dan, but i'll say it anyway. Firstly, i was a Houllier supporter. He had my support because he had a very good history with clubs. His football was attractive, he has good european contacts. Worst thing to happen for Villa was his heart problems. Now, onto McLeish. I will not step into the ground, or spend another penny on anything Villa, if that man walks into Villa Park. I will also have lost all faith in the current Villa board, which i have been beginning to already over this whole fiasco. They have just issued a statement stating their intention to interview and, basically, to hell with the vast numbers of Villa fans showing their displeasure at even the possibility of McLeish. Some will now scream that this is just an interview and doesn't mean he'll get the job, that the board are going through process. Possibly true. Some may say it's the board taking the pi55 out of the press. Again, possibly true. But what is beyond doubt is that they have managed to make the worst lead up to a managerial appointment in the history of the EPL. Aston Villa are currently the joke of English football in pretty much 100% of the media. It's a car crash. The board are showing every sign of not having a clue about football in England, god only knows who is advising them, Carson Yeung perhaps?
bacon vicious (Aston Villa): What the hell is Randy Lerner thinking? The only less popular appointment he could make would be a Middle East dictator or maybe that Serbian war criminal. This is madness.
iantaylor (Aston Villa): I've been a supporter of Aston Villa for just short of 30 years. I've spent money on Aston Villa (lots of it), for just short of 30 years. I've therefore been an investor in Aston Villa for just short of 30 years. I've seen little return on my investment in terms of success, but sure I've been blessed with many many good memories. What I have seen in that time are many false dawns. Many, many false dawns. If Villa appoint Mcleish, I'm walking away and I won't have any regrets. I'll always wish the Villa well after Mcleish is sacked but I won't return. This embarrassing pursuit, strongly outlines to me what a mug I've been taken for by the club that I invested copious amounts of money and love in. The club are charlatans. They promise much but never deliver. I'm skint. The money I do have will go elsewhere now. I'm not lining the pockets of idiots who can't manage. No more. Never again.
Simon Wilkes: I think they get my point across perfectly - and show what makes TEAMtalk such a great site.
We provide the perfect blend of breaking news, speculation and done deals, supplemented by heartfelt and passionate opinions from you, our army or readers, who are the real stars of the show.
I share your utter shock and state of disbelief that is actually unfolding.
That is all.